Option strategies
Combining options with each other or with shares to shape the payoff: covered calls, protective puts, spreads and straddles.
4 min readLesson 47 of 57Interactive
In short
Each combination trades one thing for another. A covered call earns a premium but caps the upside; a protective put limits the loss at a cost; a spread is cheaper but caps the gain; a straddle bets on a big move in either direction.
Why it matters
A single option is a blunt bet: a call on a rise, a put on a fall. Combining options with each other or with shares lets investors shape the payoff much more precisely: give up some upside for income, pay a little to cap a loss, or bet on a big move without picking a direction.
Every one of these shapes is a trade-off, never a free lunch. Learning to read a payoff diagram is how you see exactly what you give up for what you get.
How it works
A payoff diagram plots profit at expiry against the stock price. A position's line is just the sum of its parts: each option's payoff minus its premium, plus or minus the shares. Four classic shapes cover most of what people do.
A covered call: own 100 shares and sell a call above today's price. You keep the premium, which cushions a fall slightly, but if the stock rises past the strike your shares are called away, so the gain is capped. A protective put: own the shares and buy a put below today's price. The put sets a floor on the loss, like insurance, and like insurance it costs money every time, whether or not you need it.
A bull call spread: buy a call at one strike and sell a call at a higher strike. The sold call pays for part of the bought one, so it's cheaper, but the profit stops at the higher strike. The most you can lose is what you paid. A straddle: buy a call and a put at the same strike. It profits if the stock moves far in either direction, more than the two premiums combined, and loses most if the stock sits still.
Bull call spread: max profit = (higher strike − lower strike) − net cost; max loss = net cost
The spread pays at most the gap between its strikes, less what it cost to set up.
A worked example
A stock trades at $100. Three-month options priced by Black-Scholes with 20% volatility and a 4% rate: a $100 call at $4.49, a $110 call at $1.14, a $100 put at $3.49, and a $90 put at $0.58. All figures are per share.
- Bull call spread: buy the $100 call and sell the $110 call. Net cost: $4.49 − $1.14 = $3.35. Max profit: $10 − $3.35 = $6.65, at $110 or above. Breakeven: $100 + $3.35 = $103.35. Max loss: $3.35.
- Covered call: own shares at $100 and sell the $110 call for $1.14. At $120, you make $10 + $1.14 = $11.14 instead of $20. At $90, you lose $10 − $1.14 = $8.86 instead of $10.
- Protective put: own shares and buy the $90 put for $0.58. The worst case is $100 − $90 + $0.58 = $10.58 lost, however far the stock falls.
- Straddle: buy the $100 call and the $100 put for $4.49 + $3.49 = $7.98. It profits below $92.02 or above $107.98, and loses the full $7.98 if the stock ends at $100.
Result: Each strategy buys one thing with another: the spread trades upside for a lower cost, the covered call trades upside for income, the put trades a steady cost for a floor, and the straddle trades premium for a bet on a big move.
Try it
Shape the payoff
Own 100 shares bought at $100 and sell a $110 call for $1.14.
Own 100 shares bought at $100 and sell a $110 call for $1.14. It breaks even at $98.86; the most it can make is $11.14 a share and the most it can lose is $98.86 a share.
Breaks even at
$98.86
Most it can make
+$1,114
Per 100 shares
Most it can lose
−$9,886
Per 100 shares
Profit per share at expiry; a contract is 100 shares. Stock price at expiry runs from $60 on the left to $140 on the right.
How to read it
- A flat top
- The upside is capped, as in a covered call or a spread. You've sold away the big gains.
- A flat bottom
- The loss is limited, as with a protective put, a spread or any option bought. You've paid for that floor.
- A V shape
- A straddle: profit from a big move either way, with the worst result if nothing happens.
- A line falling without limit
- Unlimited risk, as when selling a call without owning the shares. Brokers restrict these for good reason.
In the real world
- Covered-call funds are popular for their steady income. Indexes that track the strategy on the S&P 500 have trailed the index itself during strong bull markets, because the upside keeps being sold away.
- Buying puts as permanent insurance is expensive. In this example, the $0.58 put costs about 2.3% a year if rolled every three months ($0.58 × 4 = $2.32 on $100), a drag that adds up over a decade.
- Straddles are a common way to trade earnings announcements, but the market prices in the expected move: the straddle's cost is roughly the move traders expect, so it only pays if the surprise is bigger than that.
- Brokers grant option permissions in levels. Covered calls and protective puts are usually allowed first; selling options without owning the shares needs the highest approval.
Common mistakes
- Treating covered-call income as free money. It's paid for with the gains you give up in the best months.
- Insuring every position all the time. Constant puts can cost more than the falls they protect against.
- Buying a straddle without checking the breakevens. The stock must move more than the combined premium just to break even.
- Forgetting that each leg has trading costs, and that a sold option can be exercised early.
See it in MarketLab
Options lab →
Draw the payoff of a covered call, protective put, bull call spread or straddle on any stock's simulated options, and see the breakevens, maximum profit and maximum loss. The drawings are for learning, but you can paper-trade single options from the chain, including covered calls and cash-secured puts, and the portfolio shows them.
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…