Return on equity
A year's profit as a percentage of shareholders' equity: how much the company earns on the money its owners have in it.
4 min readLesson 37 of 57
In short
An ROE of 20% means $20 of profit a year for every $100 of equity. Debt and share buybacks shrink equity and push ROE up, so a very high ROE can mean a great business, a heavily borrowed one, or both.
Why it matters
Profit on its own doesn't tell you how hard a company's money is working. Earning $1 billion is impressive with $5 billion invested and disappointing with $50 billion. Return on equity measures profit against the money that belongs to the shareholders, so you can judge how well a company uses what its owners have put in and left in the business.
Over long periods, companies that keep earning a high return on their equity, and can reinvest at that rate, tend to grow their earnings fastest. That's why many investors treat a high, steady ROE as a sign of a quality business.
How it works
Shareholders' equity is what would be left for the owners if the company sold everything it owns at the values on its books and paid off everything it owes. It grows when the company keeps its profits and shrinks when it pays dividends, buys back shares or makes losses. ROE divides a year's net income by it.
Debt changes the picture. A company that borrows to fund its business, or to buy back its own shares, has less equity for the same profit, so its ROE rises. That can be sensible, but it adds risk: the debt has to be repaid in bad years too. Comparing ROE with how much a company owes tells you which kind of high ROE you're looking at.
When a company has bought back so many shares that its debts exceed the book value of what it owns, equity falls below zero and ROE stops meaning anything. Several well-known, profitable companies are in that position. Then it's better to look at Profit margins, free cash flow and debt instead.
ROE = net income ÷ shareholders' equity
A year's profit for every dollar the owners have in the company.
A worked example
A company earns $2 billion a year and has $10 billion of shareholders' equity. It then borrows $4 billion and uses all of it to buy back its own shares; the interest costs it $0.2 billion a year after tax.
- ROE before: $2 billion ÷ $10 billion = 20%.
- The buyback pays $4 billion to shareholders who sell, so equity falls to $10 billion − $4 billion = $6 billion.
- Net income falls by the interest: $2 billion − $0.2 billion = $1.8 billion.
- ROE after: $1.8 billion ÷ $6 billion = 30%.
Result: ROE rose from 20% to 30% while the business itself didn't change at all and total profit fell. The higher number came from borrowing, and so did the extra risk.
How to read it
- Above about 20%, with little debt
- A business that earns a lot on its owners' money without leaning on borrowing: often a sign of a lasting edge.
- About 10% to 20%
- Solid. Many established companies, including large banks, land here in normal years.
- Below about 10%
- The company earns little on its equity: a tough, capital-hungry industry, or a weak year.
- Very high, or no figure
- Check the equity. Heavy buybacks or debt can push ROE into the hundreds of percent, and below-zero equity makes it meaningless.
In the real world
- Warren Buffett has long said he looks for businesses that earn a high return on equity without using much debt. A company that can reinvest its profits at a high rate year after year compounds its value, much like money in an account with a high interest rate.
- Some of the best-known US companies, including McDonald's and Starbucks, have reported negative shareholders' equity in recent years after spending heavily on buybacks and dividends, partly funded with debt. They're profitable businesses, but ROE can't describe them.
- Banks are judged closely on ROE because they run on borrowed money by design: deposits and debt fund most of what they lend. Regulators require them to hold minimum levels of equity, which caps how far borrowing can lift their returns.
Common mistakes
- Taking a high ROE as proof of quality without checking debt. Borrowing raises ROE and risk together.
- Comparing ROE across industries with very different needs for buildings, equipment or capital.
- Reading meaning into a huge or negative ROE when equity is tiny or below zero.
- Judging on one year. A single great or terrible year swings ROE; a steady record says more.
See it in MarketLab
Apple →
The Company numbers card shows return on equity for the last fiscal year, from SEC filings. Apple's is well above 100%, largely because years of buybacks have shrunk its equity.
Quality screen →
The screener's Quality preset asks for an ROE and a net margin of 15% or more, with revenue still growing. Companies with equity below zero have no ROE, so they drop out.
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…