Benchmark
What a result is compared with: buying and holding the same stocks, or an index like the S&P 500.
3 min readLesson 14 of 57Interactive
In short
A strategy that made +40% while simply holding made +60% did worse than doing nothing. The benchmark is the honest yardstick.
Why it matters
A result means very little on its own. A strategy that made 40% sounds great, until you learn that simply buying the same stocks and doing nothing made 60%. All that clever trading cost money. Without something to compare with, almost any positive number looks like success.
A benchmark is that something: a simple, realistic alternative you could have chosen instead. It turns "did I make money?" into the more useful question "did my choices add anything?" It's the honest yardstick for fund managers, for strategies and for your own investing.
How it works
A good benchmark is something you could actually have done, cheaply, with the same money over the same period, and it should match what you invest in. A portfolio of large US companies is usually compared with the S&P 500; a tech fund might be compared with a tech index; a bond fund with a bond index.
MarketLab's backtester offers two benchmarks. "Same stocks" buys the stocks in your test, in the same weights, on the first day and holds them to the end. That answers whether the strategy's buying and selling helped. "The market" uses the S&P 500 instead, which answers whether you'd have been better off just owning the whole market.
Compare more than the return. A strategy that trailed its benchmark slightly but with a much smaller max drawdown might still suit someone, and that's a choice worth making knowingly. The Sharpe ratio puts both sides together.
A worked example
Over five years, a moving-average crossover strategy grew $10,000 to $14,000. Buying and holding the same stocks grew it to $16,000, and the S&P 500 grew it to $15,000.
- Strategy's total return: $14,000 ÷ $10,000 − 1 = +40%.
- Same stocks, bought and held: $16,000 ÷ $10,000 − 1 = +60%. The strategy trailed by 20 percentage points, or $2,000.
- In proportion: $14,000 ÷ $16,000 = 0.875, so the strategy ended with 12.5% less money than doing nothing.
- Against the market: the S&P 500 made +50%, so the strategy trailed that by 10 points too.
Result: The strategy made money, but it did worse than both benchmarks. On return alone, the trading cost $2,000 compared with simply holding.
Try it
Strategy against its benchmark
Over two years the strategy returned −22.9% and simply holding returned +11.7%; the strategy was invested 34% of the time.
Strategy
−22.9%
Buy and hold
+11.7%
Beat the benchmark by
−34.6%
Time invested
34%
9 trades
The price started at $100.
Generated prices for illustration, not market data.
How to read it
- Beat the benchmark
- The strategy added something. Check it held up across different periods, and wasn't just luck or Overfitting.
- Matched it
- No gain from the extra effort. After real trading costs, it would probably have trailed.
- Trailed it
- Doing nothing would have been better on return. It may still have been calmer, so compare the drawdowns.
In the real world
- Fund reports show the fund's returns next to a market index. S&P's long-running SPIVA reports have found that, over 10 years or more, most actively managed funds of large US companies have trailed the S&P 500, which is a big reason index funds have grown so popular.
- Professional managers are often paid partly on how much they beat their benchmark, so the choice of benchmark matters a lot. A manager who picks an easy one can look skilled without being so.
- Investors can use the same idea at home: compare your account's return each year with a simple index fund over the same dates, including any money you added or took out.
Common mistakes
- Picking a benchmark that doesn't match. A tech-heavy portfolio compared with a bond index will look brilliant in good years and awful in bad ones.
- Comparing different periods. A strategy's last three years against an index's last ten tells you nothing.
- Comparing a total return that includes dividends with an index's price-only return.
- Judging on one period. Beating a benchmark for a year or two is common; doing it for decades is rare.
See it in MarketLab
Moving average vs holding →
Open a backtest of a 50/200-day moving-average crossover on Apple and Microsoft, compared with buying and holding the same two stocks.
Moving average vs the market →
The same strategy, compared with the S&P 500 instead.
Portfolio →
Compare your portfolio with the S&P 500, Nasdaq or Dow as growth of $100.
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…