Buy and hold
Buy good investments and keep them for years, whatever the market does in between.
3 min readLesson 49 of 57
In short
It trades almost never, so costs and taxes stay low, and it never misses the market's best days. The hard part is sitting through the falls. It's the benchmark most other strategies fail to beat.
Why it matters
Buy and hold is the simplest strategy there is, and that's exactly why it matters. It's the yardstick: any cleverer strategy has to beat it after costs, taxes and effort to be worth the trouble, and over long periods most don't.
It works because of two quiet facts. Stock markets have risen over most long stretches of history, so time in the market tends to pay. And a large share of the gains arrive on a handful of unpredictable days, often right after sharp falls. Someone who stays invested is guaranteed to be there for them.
How it works
You choose your investments, buy them once and then leave them alone. There are no signals and no timing. You don't sell because the news is bad or buy more because a stock is popular. Over time, Compounding does the work: gains, and the dividends that are reinvested, start earning gains of their own.
The choice of what to hold still matters a lot. Holding one stock for twenty years is a bet on one company, and some companies shrink or fail. Most people who follow this strategy hold a broad, diversified mix, often through index funds, so the long-run result tracks the whole market rather than one firm's luck.
The cost is emotional. A buy-and-hold investor sits through every crash in full. The broad US market has fallen by a third or more several times, and holding on through those falls is the whole strategy.
A worked example
You put $10,000 into a stock at $50 a share. Over the next year it falls to $35, then over the following years it climbs to $70.
- Shares bought: $10,000 ÷ $50 = 200 shares.
- At the low: 200 × $35 = $7,000, a 30% loss on paper.
- Holding on: 200 × $70 = $14,000, a 40% gain.
- Compare a nervous investor who sold at $35 for $7,000 and bought back once the price had recovered to $50: $7,000 ÷ $50 = 140 shares, worth 140 × $70 = $9,800 at the end.
Result: The holder ended with $14,000; the investor who sold at the low and waited for things to feel safe ended with $9,800, a 2% loss, despite owning the same stock over the same years.
How to read it
- Long bull market
- Buy and hold shines. It's fully invested the whole way up and pays no trading costs, so most active strategies trail it.
- Sharp crash and recovery
- It takes the full fall, which shows up as a deep max drawdown, but it also catches the full rebound, including the big up days that often come soon after the worst ones.
- Long sideways or falling market
- Its weakest case. A single market or stock can go a decade or more without gaining, and buy and hold simply waits.
In the real world
- Index fund investors are buy-and-hold investors. Year after year, reports comparing funds have found that the large majority of actively managed US stock funds trail a simple index over periods of ten years or more, mostly because of their higher fees and trading costs.
- Studies of the US market have found that missing only the 10 best days over a couple of decades would have cut the total gain roughly in half. Many of those best days came within weeks of the worst ones, when nervous investors had just sold.
- Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway is a famous long-term holder: it has owned its Coca-Cola shares since the late 1980s, collecting rising dividends the whole time.
Common mistakes
- Holding without Diversification. Buy and hold works for broad markets over long periods; a single stock can fall and never come back.
- Calling it buy and hold, then selling in a panic. Selling after a crash and buying back later turns a temporary loss on paper into a permanent one.
- Forgetting that time matters. Money you'll need in two years can't wait out a fall that takes five years to recover.
See it in MarketLab
Three stocks against the market →
Opens a backtest that buys Apple, JPMorgan and Coca-Cola in equal parts and holds them for five years, compared with the S&P 500.
Backtest →
Every other strategy is compared with buying and holding the same stocks, so you can see whether its trading actually helped.
Your own trading →
The Portfolio page's Review tab compares your account with what it would be worth had you never traded again after your first week: your own buy-and-hold yardstick.
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…