ETFs and index funds
Funds that buy a whole basket of stocks, often a full index like the S&P 500, in one share.
4 min readLesson 3 of 57
In short
One purchase spreads your money over hundreds of companies, for a small yearly fee. They're the simplest way to get the market's return, which most professional stock pickers fail to beat after costs.
Why it matters
Picking individual stocks takes time, research and nerve, and most people who try, including professionals, end up doing worse than the market. A fund that simply owns the whole market sidesteps that problem: you can't pick the wrong company if you own them all.
Index funds and ETFs made this cheap and easy. With one purchase you get Diversification across hundreds of companies, for a yearly fee that can be a small fraction of a percent. For many long-term investors, they're the core of the portfolio.
How it works
An index is a list of companies with a rule for how much of each to hold. The S&P 500 holds about 500 large US companies, weighted by market cap, so the biggest companies count the most. An index fund buys the companies in the list in the same proportions, so its value rises and falls with the index, minus its costs.
The yearly fee is the expense ratio, taken out of the fund's value a little at a time. Large index funds charge as little as a few hundredths of a percent; actively managed funds, where a manager picks stocks, often charge several times more.
ETF stands for exchange-traded fund: it trades on a stock exchange like a share, at a market price that changes during the day. A traditional mutual fund is bought and sold directly from the fund company once a day, at that day's closing value. Many ETFs track an index, and many index funds are mutual funds; the index is about what the fund holds, the ETF label is about how you buy it.
Your return ≈ index return − expense ratio
An index fund aims to deliver what the index did, less its yearly fee and a little tracking error.
A worked example
You invest $10,000 for 30 years in a fund tracking an index that returns 7% a year. One fund charges 0.05% a year; another charges 1%.
- Cheap fund: 7% − 0.05% = 6.95% a year. $10,000 × 1.0695 ^ 30 ≈ $75,063.
- Expensive fund: 7% − 1% = 6% a year. $10,000 × 1.06 ^ 30 ≈ $57,435.
- Difference: $75,063 − $57,435 = $17,628.
Result: Both funds held the same stocks, but the 1% fee cost $17,628, almost a quarter of the cheap fund's final value, because the fee compounds year after year.
How to read it
- Expense ratio under 0.1%
- Typical of large index funds. The fee barely dents your return.
- Around 0.5% to 1%
- Common for actively managed funds. The manager has to beat the index by that much every year just to keep up.
- Broad index
- Hundreds or thousands of companies, like the S&P 500 or a total-market fund. Wide diversification in one share.
- Narrow or themed fund
- One sector, country or trend. Still a basket, but a concentrated one, with much more risk than a broad index.
In the real world
- John Bogle's Vanguard launched the first index mutual fund for ordinary investors in 1976, and it was widely mocked at the time. The first US ETF, the SPDR S&P 500 fund (ticker SPY), followed in 1993. Index funds now hold trillions of dollars, and SPY is one of the most traded securities in the world.
- Regular studies, such as S&P's SPIVA reports, have found that most actively managed US stock funds trail their index over periods of ten years or more, after fees. Some managers beat the market in a given year, but few do it consistently, and it's hard to tell them apart in advance.
- Many workplace retirement plans now offer index funds or target-date funds built from them, and many advisers suggest a broad, low-cost index fund as the core of a long-term portfolio. That isn't a promise of good returns: an index fund falls when the market falls, as S&P 500 funds did by more than half from late 2007 to early 2009.
Common mistakes
- Assuming every ETF is diversified. A fund holding 30 companies in one industry is far riskier than a broad index fund.
- Overlooking fees. Two funds tracking the same index can charge very different amounts, and the difference compounds.
- Buying several funds that hold the same stocks. Three S&P 500 funds give the same diversification as one.
- Trading ETFs often because they're easy to trade. Frequent buying and selling adds costs and tends to hurt returns.
See it in MarketLab
Dashboard →
The market indices on the dashboard are shown through the funds that track them: SPY for the S&P 500, QQQ for the Nasdaq and DIA for the Dow.
Against the market →
Backtests can compare any strategy with the S&P 500. This one holds two volatile stocks against it: notice how much wider their swings are than the index's.
Portfolio →
Your portfolio's performance chart compares you with the S&P 500, Nasdaq or Dow, the return an index fund would have given you.
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…