Margin and margin calls
Money set aside to back a short (or a loan), and the forced buy-back when the account's equity falls too low.
4 min readLesson 27 of 57
In short
Here a short needs 150% of its value set aside: the sale's proceeds plus half as much again. If the price rises until equity (cash plus what you own, less what you're short) is under 30% of the shorts' value, shorts are bought back at that close until it's restored, at whatever the price is then. Brokers' rules are similar.
Why it matters
When you sell short, you owe shares you don't have. The broker needs to know you can buy them back, so it holds money aside as security: margin. As long as your account is worth enough compared with what you owe, nothing happens.
When it isn't, the broker acts without asking. A margin call is the forced buy-back that follows, at whatever the price is that day. It turns a paper loss into a real one, often at the worst moment, so it's worth understanding before you go short.
How it works
Your equity is what the account is worth: cash, plus the stocks you own, minus the value of your shorts, with any options at their latest marks. Selling short doesn't change equity on the day: the proceeds add to cash exactly what the short subtracts.
MarketLab checks equity at every close. If it has fallen below 30% of the shorts' value, the maintenance margin, it buys shorts back at that close, largest first and in whole shares, just until equity is back to 30%. If there isn't enough cash, it sells stocks you own first to raise it. These trades show in your activity, marked as a margin call.
The buy-back doesn't raise equity, since it swaps cash for a smaller short at the market price. It works by shrinking the shorts, and so the 30% you need. Separately, each short also has 150% of its value set aside when you open it (see short selling), which limits how big a short you can start.
As the price rises, the short's value grows and equity falls at the same time, so a big enough rise always triggers a call. You can work out the price that would do it in advance.
equity = cash + longs − shorts; margin call if equity < 30% × shorts
Once what you're worth falls below 30% of what you owe in shares, shorts are bought back until it isn't.
A worked example
You have $10,000.00 in cash and sell 300 shares short at $50.00. Your cash becomes $25,000.00, and you're short $15,000.00 of stock. Leave borrow fees aside.
- Equity: $25,000.00 − $15,000.00 = $10,000.00, unchanged. A call comes once $25,000.00 − 300 × price is under 30% of 300 × price, which happens above $25,000.00 ÷ 390 = $64.10.
- The stock jumps and closes at $70.00. The shorts are now worth 300 × $70.00 = $21,000.00, so equity is $25,000.00 − $21,000.00 = $4,000.00. The 30% required is $6,300.00.
- A short of S shares stays within the rule if $4,000.00 ≥ 30% × $70.00 × S, so at most 190 shares. MarketLab buys back 110 shares at $70.00, for $7,700.00.
- Afterwards: cash $17,300.00, a short of 190 shares worth $13,300.00, and equity still $4,000.00. The requirement is now 30% × $13,300.00 = $3,990.00, so the account is back within the rule.
Result: A 40% rise turned $10,000 into $4,000, and the margin call locked in the loss on 110 shares at the day's close. If the stock falls back later, those shares are no longer short.
How to read it
- Equity well above 30% of shorts
- Room to spare. Work out the price that would trigger a call, and how far away it is.
- Equity near 30% of shorts
- A small rise triggers a forced buy-back. Covering some yourself lets you choose which and when.
- A margin call in your activity
- Shorts were bought back at that close, the largest first, just enough to restore 30%.
- Buying power below zero
- The 150% set aside for shorts has grown past your cash as prices rose. You can't buy more until it's back above zero.
In the real world
- In the US, Regulation T requires 150% for opening a short: the proceeds plus 50%. Exchange rules set a minimum maintenance margin of 30% for most shorts, and brokers often ask for more on volatile stocks.
- Real brokers usually send a margin call first and give a little time to add cash, but they may also sell without warning, and they choose what to sell.
- Margin also means borrowing to buy stocks. In 1929, many investors had bought with mostly borrowed money; as prices fell, margin calls forced selling that drove prices lower still.
Common mistakes
- Not knowing the price that would trigger a call until it happens.
- Assuming a stock that has risen must come back before you're forced out. A margin call doesn't wait.
- Thinking buying back raises your equity. It only shrinks what you're required to hold.
See it in MarketLab
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…