Short selling
Selling borrowed shares now to buy them back later, so you gain if the price falls and lose if it rises.
4 min readLesson 26 of 57
In short
Sell 100 shares short at $50 and buy them back at $40: you keep $1,000, less fees. But a stock can rise without limit, so a short's possible loss has no ceiling. While short you pay a borrow fee and any dividends the stock pays.
Why it matters
Buying a stock is a bet that it will rise. Short selling is the opposite: a way to profit when a price falls. Funds use it to bet against companies they think are overvalued, and to hedge, offsetting some of the risk of what they own.
It's also riskier than buying in a way that's easy to miss. A stock you buy can at worst go to zero. A stock you're short can rise without any limit, so the loss has no ceiling, and the costs of staying short add up every day.
How it works
To sell short, you borrow shares and sell them now, then buy them back later and return them. If the price fell in between, you keep the difference. In MarketLab you choose Short on a stock's trade card, and a later buy covers it: buying the shares back closes the short.
The sale's proceeds go into your cash, but you can't spend them. MarketLab sets aside 150% of the short's value at the latest price: the proceeds plus half as much again from your own money. That set-aside reduces your buying power, and it grows if the price rises. If it rises far enough, a margin call buys the shares back for you.
While you're short you pay to borrow: a fee of 3% a year, charged at each close on the short's value at that close, divided by 252 trading days. If the stock pays a Dividend, you pay it, since the lender would have received it. A stock split scales the short just as it would shares you own.
You can't sell a stock short while you own shares of it; sell those first. Shorts are allowed in season (competition) portfolios too.
profit = shares × (sale price − buy-back price) − borrow fees − dividends paid
You gain what the price fell, less what it cost to stay short.
A worked example
A stock closes at $50.00. You sell 100 shares short.
- The sale puts $5,000.00 into your cash. MarketLab sets aside 150% of it, $7,500.00: the proceeds plus $2,500.00 of your own money, so your buying power falls by $2,500.00.
- Borrow fee for a close with the price still at $50.00: 3% × $5,000.00 ÷ 252 = $0.60.
- The price falls to $40.00 and you buy the shares back for $4,000.00. That's $1,000.00 gained before fees.
- Say you were short for 21 closes, at an average value of $4,500.00. The fees come to 21 × 3% × $4,500.00 ÷ 252 = $11.25, leaving $988.75.
- Had the price risen to $65.00 instead, buying back would cost $6,500.00, a loss of $1,500.00, and the amount set aside would have grown to 150% × $6,500.00 = $9,750.00.
Result: A 20% fall made about $1,000, but a 30% rise lost $1,500, and a stock can keep rising. Shorts gain less from a fall than they can lose from a rise.
How to read it
- Price falls after you short
- You gain the fall, less the borrow fee for each close and any dividends.
- Price rises after you short
- You lose the rise, more is set aside, and buying power shrinks. There's no upper limit.
- Buying power drops when you short
- Normal: half the short's value from your own money is set aside on top of the proceeds.
- A dividend while short
- Taken from your cash, since you owe it to the lender of the shares.
In the real world
- Real brokers lend shares from other customers' accounts. Popular shorts can be hard to borrow and cost far more than 3% a year, sometimes over 50%, and a lender can recall the shares.
- When many shorts rush to buy back at once, their buying pushes the price higher still: a short squeeze. GameStop's rise of over 1,000% in January 2021 forced large losses on funds that were short.
- Short sellers have exposed frauds such as Enron and Wirecard, and studies find heavily shorted stocks tend to do poorly afterwards. Many funds use shorts mainly to hedge, as in pairs trading.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting the loss is unlimited, and making a short as big as a long you'd be comfortable with.
- Ignoring the borrow fee and dividends, which add up on a short held for months.
- Shorting a stock just because it has risen a lot. Rising stocks often keep rising for a while; see Momentum rotation.
See it in MarketLab
Tesla's trade card →
Choose Short on the trade card to sell shares you don't own. To close the short, buy the shares back from the same card. A volatile stock shows how fast a short can go against you.
Holdings →
A short shows as a negative number of shares, with its value, its gain or loss, and the borrow fees and dividends it has paid in your activity.
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…