Rebalancing
Selling some of what grew and buying what shrank, to get back to the mix you chose.
3 min readLesson 51 of 57Interactive
In short
Left alone, the winners take over a portfolio and its risk drifts upward. Rebalancing on a schedule keeps the risk where you set it, and quietly makes you sell high and buy low.
Why it matters
When you pick a mix, say 60% stocks and 40% bonds, you're choosing how much risk to take. But the mix doesn't stay put. Whatever grows fastest takes up more and more of the portfolio, and after a long rally you may hold far more stocks, and far more risk, than you signed up for.
Rebalancing pulls the portfolio back to the mix you chose. It's a discipline more than a way to boost returns: it keeps the risk steady, and it makes you do something most people find hard, which is to sell some of what's been winning and buy what's been lagging.
How it works
On a schedule, you work out each holding's share of the total and compare it with its target. Then you sell what's above target and buy what's below until every weight is back where it started. Some investors use a calendar, such as once a quarter or once a year; others rebalance only when a weight drifts past a band, such as five points.
In MarketLab's backtester, the portfolio starts at your chosen weights and is reset to them at the start of every month, or every third month for quarterly, counting from the start of the test.
How often matters less than people expect. Rebalancing too often adds trading costs and, in a taxable account, taxes on the gains you sell. Too rarely, and the mix can drift a long way. Many investors settle on once or twice a year.
Amount to trade = target weight × total value − current value of the holding
A positive number means buy that much; a negative one means sell it.
A worked example
You invest $10,000 at 60% stocks and 40% bonds: $6,000 and $4,000. In the first year stocks rise 30% and bonds 5%.
- After a year: stocks $6,000 × 1.30 = $7,800, bonds $4,000 × 1.05 = $4,200, total $12,000.
- Drift: stocks are now $7,800 ÷ $12,000 = 65% of the portfolio, not 60%.
- Rebalance: the stock target is 60% × $12,000 = $7,200, so sell $600 of stocks and buy $600 of bonds, leaving $7,200 and $4,800.
- The next year stocks fall 20% and bonds are flat. Rebalanced: $7,200 × 0.8 + $4,800 = $10,560. Not rebalanced: $7,800 × 0.8 + $4,200 = $10,440.
Result: Rebalancing locked in some of the stock gains before the fall and left the portfolio $120 ahead. Had stocks kept rising instead, the untouched portfolio would have come out ahead, but with more risk along the way.
Try it
Drift, and getting back on target
Share of the portfolio in stocks: left alone it drifts from 60% to 69%; rebalanced it stays near 60%.
Stocks after 5 years, left alone
69%
Worst fall −19%
Stocks after 5 years, rebalanced
60%
Worst fall −20%
Return, alone / rebalanced
+61.2% / +60.7%
Five years of generated stock and bond prices.
How to read it
- Long bull market in one asset
- Rebalancing usually trails letting it ride, because it keeps trimming the winner. In exchange, the risk stays where you set it.
- Sideways, back-and-forth market
- Its best case. Selling after rises and buying after falls can add a little return as prices swing around a level.
- Crash
- A portfolio that was rebalanced falls less, because it held less of the asset that crashed, and the next rebalance buys more of it while it's cheap.
In the real world
- Target-date retirement funds and balanced funds rebalance automatically to keep their mix of stocks and bonds on target, so their investors don't have to.
- Pension funds and university endowments set target weights for each type of asset, with ranges around them, and rebalance when holdings stray outside those ranges.
- Many investors avoid selling, and the taxes that come with it, by rebalancing with new money instead: they direct each new contribution to whatever is below its target.
Common mistakes
- Expecting it to raise returns. Its main job is controlling risk; when one asset keeps winning for years, rebalancing will usually end lower.
- Rebalancing so often that costs and taxes eat the benefit. Small drifts of a point or two rarely matter.
- Abandoning it in a crash. Buying what just fell feels wrong, but that's exactly when the discipline does its job.
See it in MarketLab
Test yourself
Optional: 4 quick questions on the words, using the idea, and how it plays out in real markets.
Loading your answers…